052-5927592 17 Tzahal Street, Ness Ziona Sun-Thu 09:00-19:00, Fri 09:00-12:30

A creditor of the seller attached the apartment you bought: why the cautionary note is decisive

When you buy an apartment and do not register a cautionary note immediately, a creditor of the seller may impose an attachment on the rights still registered in the seller's name. The case law has since changed in buyers' favour, but this still means costly and lengthy proceedings. In a case heard in the Haifa Magistrates' Court, the lawyer who did not register a note was held liable for negligence.

A cautionary note is an entry in the Land Registry recording the owner's undertaking to enter into a transaction, and it prevents the registration of a conflicting transaction, under sections 126 and 127 of the Land Law, 5729-1969.

Written by Amos Ilan, Advocate and NotaryPublished: Updated: Reading time: 3 minutes

What happened in the case?

In 1990 a woman bought a quarter of an apartment from a family member who had fallen into debt. It was an inherited apartment. The same lawyer represented both parties. The transaction was reported to the tax authorities only 3 years later; no cautionary note was registered at all, and the rights were not transferred. In 1994 a creditor of the seller imposed an attachment on the quarter that was still registered in his name. The cautionary note was registered only after the attachment.

The buyer's attempt to have the attachment removed in the District Court failed, and she was ordered to pay costs. At the time, a long-standing rule known as the Bokar rule prevailed, under which a creditor who had attached the property took priority over a buyer who had not registered her right. The negligent lawyer who had handled the sale transaction also handled the claim, and it was he who advised against filing an appeal. The buyer's heirs sued the lawyer for negligence.

This is where matters became complicated. The lawyer issued a third-party notice against the insurance company with which he held professional liability insurance. The insurance company in turn issued a third-party notice (in effect, a fourth-party notice) against the seller, arguing that if the lawyer were found negligent and the insurer were then held liable to pay off the attachment, the seller would be unjustly enriched, having both received the purchase price and had his debts paid.

The author of this article represented the seller pro bono. The seller was in fact the only person among all those involved who had behaved properly and had not been negligent at all. His circumstances did not allow him to fund the proceedings.

The court held that the lawyer had been negligent and awarded against him the value of the quarter of the apartment, taking into account that it was subject to a lifelong right of residence, together with reimbursement of the costs of the earlier proceedings. At the end of the proceedings, the notice against our client was dismissed and the insurance company was even ordered to pay costs. The argument that the claim was premature and theoretical was accepted, since nothing had been paid when the claim was filed. That may not have been the most correct legal outcome, but justice was done here.

How has the case law changed since?

Since the Aharonov ruling of 1999, the right of a buyer who has signed and paid can take priority over an attachment imposed after the transaction, even without a cautionary note. The rule was later qualified, and in any case taking priority over the attachment requires court proceedings, while a note registered on the day of signing prevents this from the outset.

In 1999, in the Aharonov ruling (CA 189/95 Bank Otzar Ha-Hayal v. Aharonov, PD 53(4) 199), an expanded panel of seven Supreme Court justices held that the right of a buyer who has signed and paid can take priority over an attachment imposed after the transaction, even if no cautionary note was registered. According to the majority, the buyer holds a "quasi-proprietary" right under section 9 of the Land Law, while an attachment is a procedural tool that catches only what the debtor still has in the property. In effect, the Bokar rule was overturned. The judgment in Haifa mentions this change, because had an appeal been filed against the dismissal of the claim to remove the attachment, that appeal would have succeeded, since the Aharonov ruling was handed down at the same time as the appeal. A twist of fate.

The rule did not remain without qualifications. In the judgment itself, Justice Dorner noted that a buyer who failed to register out of real negligence, let alone an intention to mislead, may be regarded as insisting on his right in bad faith, especially where the creditor relied on the property belonging to the seller. In 2008 the Supreme Court qualified the rule for an undertaking to give an apartment as a gift (CA 11502/05 Laniado v. Holland Israel Ltd). For an unregistered gift the starting point is reversed: the attaching creditor prevails, unless the donee proves that the gift was made in good faith and not to remove the property from the creditors' reach. In that case no cautionary note had been registered for years, and the attachment prevailed.

But the new rule does not make the cautionary note redundant. To prevail over the attachment you have to go to court, prove good faith, payment and dates, and bear the costs of the proceedings. A note registered on the day of signing prevents all this from the outset: an attachment imposed after it is registered does not prejudice the buyer's rights (section 127(b) of the Land Law).

What does the case teach about dual representation?

There is not much to learn from this particular case, as it involved gross negligence in representation. As a general rule, however, when the same lawyer represents both buyer and seller, it is hard for that lawyer genuinely to look after the interests of each party. In this case the lawyer knew that the seller was in debt and still failed to register a note; moreover, the lawyer was acting for the buyer, and the seller was not separately represented at all.

What needs to be done on the day of signing?

On the day of signing, obtain an up-to-date Land Registry extract and check for attachments, mortgages and notes, sign an application to register a cautionary note together with the contract, and file it immediately. Report the transaction to the Israel Tax Authority on time, and do not transfer money before the security is in place.

The declaration to the Tax Authority is filed within 30 days of the date of sale (section 73 of the Real Estate Taxation (Betterment and Purchase) Law, 5723-1963), and purchase tax is generally paid within 60 days.

Sources

  • CA 189/95 Bank Otzar Ha-Hayal Ltd v. Aharonov, PD 53(4) 199 (16 August 1999).
  • CA 11502/05 Laniado v. Holland Israel Ltd (24 February 2008).
  • Land Law, 5729-1969: section 9 (conflicting transactions), section 127(b) (a cautionary note against a later attachment). Hebrew.

The judgments were read in full and the statute checked on 23 October 2026.

When should you consult a lawyer?

Before signing a contract to buy an apartment or a share in one, send us the extract and the draft contract. We will check that your rights are protected from day one.

To arrange a call: 052-5927592, or on WhatsApp using the button on the site.

About the author

Amos Ilan is an advocate (Israel Bar no. 35320) and a notary (licence no. 214444). The office is at 17 Tzahal Street, Ness Ziona, and handles real estate transactions, construction defects, condominium disputes and civil litigation.

Disclaimer. This article describes a case that has concluded and is presented for general information only. It does not constitute legal advice or a promise of a similar outcome. Every case depends on its own facts and documents, so it is advisable to consult a lawyer before taking any step.

Questions and answers

What is a cautionary note?

An entry in the Land Registry (Tabu) that gives notice to everyone that an undertaking has been made to you in respect of the property. It prevents conflicting transactions and protects you against the seller's creditors.

I registered a note after the attachment. What now?

Under the Aharonov rule you have a good chance of having the attachment removed, but it requires legal proceedings. It is advisable to act quickly.

Can I sue the lawyer who did not register a note?

Yes, if the lawyer was negligent and you suffered loss as a result. In the case described, the lawyer was ordered to pay the value of the rights that were lost.

Need your situation checked? Let's start with a conversation

Send us the documents you have, and we will tell you what the next step is.

Call WhatsApp Form